The Trump administration said it intends to detonate lead explosives in Iowa this week despite a court order temporarily blocking it, pointing to the risk of an uncontrolled explosion in cold weather that makes it too dangerous to wait.
In court filings Saturday, Justice Department attorneys laid out why the Army plans to use emergency authority granted by the Environmental Protection Agency to move forward without a permit, and an Army official for the first time described in greater detail how the situation became so dangerous.
The 68 barrels of degrading lead azide at the Iowa Army Ammunition Plant are crystallizing, and the crystals are more likely to break in cold temperatures, setting off an explosive chain reaction that could “cause an uncontrolled dispersal of lead azide into the environment,” the DOJ filing says. Temperatures are forecast to drop below freezing Sunday night and then into the low twenties Monday and Tuesday night.
And the Army said its preparations to detonate the explosives have made the situation even more dangerous and cannot be reversed, since heavy metal blast doors were removed and replaced with temporary plywood insulated with foam.
Trending
“The bunkers, where the barrels are located, are now more vulnerable to temperature changes because the blast doors were removed in preparation of the controlled detonation and cannot be replaced,” the DOJ filing says.
The Army has been under intense pressure from Iowa and Illinois leaders and from environmental groups, all urging the Defense Department to delay its plan to deliberately destroy the lead azide in an effort to avoid an uncontrolled explosion from the volatile substance. Iowa Gov. Kim Reynolds said she was not notified of the Army’s plan until Monday, when it first published maps that showed the possibility of a toxic lead dust plume stretching over parts of Iowa and into Illinois.
Environmental groups filed a lawsuit Thursday intended to delay the explosion, and on Friday the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals temporarily blocked the EPA’s emergency permit. The detonation is currently scheduled to take place Monday.
The Trump administration’s legal response Saturday confirms that the Army intends to blow up the explosives without a permit even if the court decides to continue blocking it, exercising emergency authority granted by the EPA.
In the event of an uncontrolled detonation, the filing describes the dangerous scenarios envisioned by Army experts. An uncontrolled explosion could send lead into the air over unprepared surrounding communities, causing public panic. Some of the lead azide could be jettisoned into other parts of the ammunition plant, undetonated in the initial reaction, necessitating secondary explosions in areas also unprepared for such work.
“Unfavorable winds could increase the dispersion of lead dust into the community,” the DOJ filing said. “An uncontrolled deportation of nearly five tons of primary explosive would endanger soldiers, contractors, and the surrounding communities, all without many of the protective measures meant to minimize the risks from the blast — harm that cannot be undone.”
An Army official, Aaron Teller, in a court declaration, said the Army found that 58 of the 68 barrels have crystallization present around their lids during a late April inspection, meaning the lids of the barrels aren’t safe to remove. The Army first discovered there was a problem with the barrels in March, during a routine inspection, and then prohibited Army personnel from accessing the barrels at that point onward, according to EPA permitting documents obtained by The Washington Sun.
A contractor — American Ordnance — is usually in charge of opening the barrel lids every September to refill the liquid that historically has covered the lead azide and is used to prevent crystallization. But this year, the contractor has not refilled the liquid because of the safety issues, increasing the risks, Teller said in the declaration.
The Army has been preparing mitigation measures for more than a month, building barriers around the site where the lead azide is stored and planning to soak the area ahead of and after the explosion to limit lead dust dispersion.
The environmental groups challenging the Army’s plan also filed a declaration Sunday from explosives and EPA experts, who said that they believed the Army’s mitigation measures would have significantly reduced the risk of explosion from quickly falling temperatures.
“Based on my training and experience, the storage conditions described in EPA’s permit, and historical and forecast weather for the Burlington area, it is my opinion that the forecast weather does not support the Army’s position that the detonation must occur no later than November 23, 2026,” wrote Mark J. Thomas, a retired EPA official from Region 7, the area that oversees the ammunition plant.
The Army reviewed the possibility of using chemicals to destroy the lead azide instead of blowing it up, but doing so would have required opening the lids of the barrels, which experts deemed too dangerous and risked causing unintentional explosions, according to an early September letter from Army officials to the EPA. On May 8, then-Army Secretary Dan Driscoll determined that intentionally detonating the lead was the safest approach, according to the letter.
The Army hired a contractor in April to explore that chemical approach but then canceled the contract two months later for safety reasons, according to The New York Times. The contract was worth $30,000 and cancelled on May 27, according to federal government contracting records reviewed by The Sun.
Correction: A previous version of this story incorrectly reported which Army official filed a court declaration.